Product Image

Men's Formula

SmartyPants
4.2
(273 ratings)
Choline 12 mg
Vitamin K 36 mcg
Iodine 150 mcg
Lycopene 8 mg
Fish Oil 510 mg
Coenzyme Q10 60 mg
Product Image
Score 65.0

A convenient gummy multivitamin for men, offering a wide array of essential nutrients and some beneficial additions like CoQ10 and Lycopene. It uses high-quality forms of B vitamins, but the overall efficacy is tempered by low dosages of some key ingredients and a notable sugar content per serving.

Quantity: 120 Gummy(ies)Servings size: 6 Gummy(ies) (20 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Brain Health
Cognitive Support
Mental Focus
Productivity Boost
Metabolism Boost

Score 65.0

A convenient gummy multivitamin for men, offering a wide array of essential nutrients and some beneficial additions like CoQ10 and Lycopene. It uses high-quality forms of B vitamins, but the overall efficacy is tempered by low dosages of some key ingredients and a notable sugar content per serving.

Quantity: 180
Analysis

SmartyPants Men's Formula is a multi-ingredient gummy vitamin designed for men's overall health, covering a wide range of goals from brain health to metabolism and anti-aging. Its appeal lies primarily in its ease of consumption due to the gummy form, which makes it a popular choice for many. The product notably includes well-absorbed forms of critical nutrients like L-Methylfolate and Methylcobalamin (Vitamin B12), and features beneficial additions such as CoQ10, Lycopene, and Vitamin K2 (Menaquinone-7), which are often lacking in basic multivitamins. Online reviews generally praise the taste and convenience, leading to its high popularity (evidenced by the large review count for ID 151968, which is the same product in a larger pack). However, a significant drawback is the high sugar content per serving (9 grams, 45 calories), which nutritionists frequently caution against in daily supplements. Furthermore, while the range of ingredients is broad, the dosages for several key components, especially fish oil (omega-3s), choline, and inositol, are considerably lower than what is generally recommended for therapeutic benefits, or even for meeting daily adequate intake in the case of choline. The fish oil content lacks specific EPA/DHA breakdown, which are the most beneficial components. This blend of good intentions with compromises in dosage and added sugar positions it as a good entry-level multi-vitamin for general nutrient gap filling, but not necessarily a high-potency solution for specific health goals.

Pros
  • Convenient and palatable gummy format, ideal for those who struggle with pills.
  • Contains high-quality, bioavailable forms of Folate (L-Methylfolate) and Vitamin B12 (Methylcobalamin).
  • Includes beneficial supplementary ingredients like CoQ10, Lycopene, and Vitamin K2.
  • Provides a comprehensive range of essential vitamins and minerals for general health.
Cons
  • High sugar content (9g) and calories (45) per serving, which can be a concern for daily intake.
  • Low dosages of several key ingredients, such as fish oil (unspecified EPA/DHA), choline, and inositol, limit their effectiveness.
  • Requires consuming 6 gummies per serving, which some users might find excessive.
  • Price per serving is relatively high for the ingredient dosages provided, especially considering the sugar content.
Warnings
  • Individuals with dietary sugar restrictions or those monitoring calorie intake should be aware of the high sugar and calorie content.
  • The general low dosage for some ingredients means it might not adequately address specific deficiencies or therapeutic needs without additional supplementation.
  • Contains fish oil; individuals with fish allergies should avoid.
$20.34($1.01 per serving)
Walmart
$ 20.34
Ingredients
IngredientAmount per serving
Calories 45 Calorie(s)
Total Fat 0.5 Gram(s)
Cholesterol 5 mg
Total Carbohydrates 9 Gram(s)
Vitamin A (Retinyl Palmitate, Beta-Carotene) 270 mcg
Vitamin C (Ascorbic Acid) 45 mg
Vitamin D (Vitamin D3, Cholecalciferol) 40 mcg
Vitamin E (D-Alpha-Tocopherol) 9 mg
Vitamin K (Vitamin K-1) 36 mcg
Thiamine (Vitamin B1, Thiamine Mononitrate) 0.12 mg
Riboflavin (Vitamin B2) 0.26 mg
Niacin (Vitamin B3, Inositol Niacinate) 4 mg
Vitamin B-6 (Pyridoxal 5-Phosphate) 1.7 mg
Folate (L-Methylfolate, Calcium Salt) 400 mcg DFE
Vitamin B12 (Methylcobalamin) 4 mcg
Biotin 15 mcg
Choline (Choline Bitartrate) 12 mg
Iodine (Potassium Iodide) 150 mcg
Zinc (Zinc Citrate) 11 mg
Selenium (Sodium Selenite) 14 mcg
Sodium 25 mg
Fish Oil 510 mg
Lycopene 8 mg
Coenzyme Q10 (Ubiquinone) 60 mg
Inositol (Inositol Niacinate) 1 mg
Vitamin K-2 (Menaquinone-7) 16 mcg
Gluten Free Men 18–50 Dairy Free
Categories
Vitamin K 85.0
The product includes both Vitamin K1 (36mcg) and Vitamin K2 (Menaquinone-7, 16mcg), which is excellent. K2 in the MK-7 form is highly bioavailable and particularly beneficial for bone and cardiovascular health, making this a strong point of the formulation.
Iodine 75.0
With 150mcg of Iodine (as Potassium Iodide), the product meets the daily recommended intake for adults, providing good support for thyroid function and overall metabolism. This is a standard and effective dose.
Lycopene 70.0
The 8mg of Lycopene is a reasonable dose for an antioxidant and for general prostate and cardiovascular health support in a multivitamin context. It's a good inclusion for a men's formula.
Goals
Bone Health 75.0
The product stands out by including a solid dose of Vitamin D3 (40mcg/1600IU) along with Vitamin K (K1 and K2 as MK-7). This combination is highly beneficial for calcium absorption and utilization, directing calcium to bones and away from arteries, thus providing good support for bone density.
General Health 70.0
The product offers a decent spectrum of essential vitamins and minerals crucial for overall bodily functions. While it provides good forms of some vitamins, the lower dosages of certain beneficial ingredients like fish oil and choline might not offer optimal support for comprehensive general health beyond basic nutritional gaps.
Heart Health 70.0
CoQ10 (60mg) and Fish Oil (510mg, though EPA/DHA not specified) are important for cardiovascular function. Vitamin K2 also contributes to arterial health. While the fish oil dose is somewhat low, the combination of these ingredients offers a foundational level of support for heart health.
85 Value

Multi For Him

Nature Made
4.7
(1806 ratings)
This tablet multivitamin provides a solid and balanced profile of essential vitamins and minerals tailored for men at a very competitive price point ($0.11 per serving). It delivers good value for comprehensive daily nutritional support without the added sugars of gummies, offering a better balance of cost and efficacy.
80 Value

Daily Vits

NOW
4.7
(9895 ratings)
Priced at $0.19 per serving, this multivitamin offers a good balance of essential nutrients, including Lycopene, and a fruit/veggie blend, providing a more robust nutritional profile than SmartyPants for a similar or lower price point. It's a well-rounded option for general health without the high sugar content.
90 Value

Omega 3 Platinum

Zahler
4.8
(1395 ratings)
Although more expensive per serving ($0.69), this product delivers a very high dose of quality Kosher TG Fish Oil (3000mg with 1860mg Omega-3s) compared to the unspecified 510mg in SmartyPants gummies. For specific fish oil benefits, this is a far superior value despite the higher initial cost, offering concentrated and bioavailable Omega-3s.
95 Performance

Two-Per-Day Capsules

Life Extension
4.7
(85932 ratings)
This multi offers significantly higher and more bioavailable forms of many vitamins and minerals compared to SmartyPants, including potent doses of B vitamins, Vitamin D3, and a robust antioxidant blend with Lycopene and CoQ10. Its comprehensive formulation and superior ingredient forms make it a much more effective choice for overall health support, though at a higher price.
90 Performance

Men's Once Daily

Garden of Life MyKind Organics
4.8
(2878 ratings)
This organic, whole-food based multivitamin offers a distinct advantage for those preferring natural sources, providing a good profile of essential nutrients, including Lycopene and a solid Vitamin K dose. While its potency isn't always higher than synthetic multis, its whole-food approach and clean label make it a superior choice for specific consumer preferences.
92 Performance

Super Ubiquinol CoQ10 with Enhanced Mitochondrial Support 100 mg

Life Extension
4.7
(8037 ratings)
While a specialized product, it offers a superior and more potent form of CoQ10 (Ubiquinol at 100mg) compared to the Ubiquinone in SmartyPants, along with Shilajit for enhanced mitochondrial support. For individuals specifically targeting heart health and cellular energy, this is a significantly more effective option than the multi-purpose gummy.
85 Budget

B-50

NOW
4.7
(4265 ratings)
At a price per serving of $0.10, this product is significantly more affordable and provides a comprehensive B-complex, including higher doses of Choline and Inositol, which are components of the SmartyPants formula. It focuses on energy and neurological support, offering good value for those specific benefits.
90 Budget

Choline & Inositol

NOW
4.8
(19061 ratings)
This product offers Choline (250mg) and Inositol (250mg) at a much lower price per serving ($0.08) than SmartyPants, providing substantially higher and more effective dosages of these two specific nutrients. It's a highly targeted and cost-effective option for those prioritizing Choline and Inositol benefits.
75 Budget

Sentry Adults

21st Century
4.7
(23601 ratings)
This is a highly affordable comprehensive multivitamin at $0.04 per serving, covering a wide array of vitamins and minerals similar to SmartyPants, though in tablet form. It provides excellent general health support for a fraction of the cost, making it a budget-friendly alternative.
85 Value

Multi For Him

Nature Made
4.7
(1806 ratings)
This tablet multivitamin provides a solid and balanced profile of essential vitamins and minerals tailored for men at a very competitive price point ($0.11 per serving). It delivers good value for comprehensive daily nutritional support without the added sugars of gummies, offering a better balance of cost and efficacy.
80 Value

Daily Vits

NOW
4.7
(9895 ratings)
Priced at $0.19 per serving, this multivitamin offers a good balance of essential nutrients, including Lycopene, and a fruit/veggie blend, providing a more robust nutritional profile than SmartyPants for a similar or lower price point. It's a well-rounded option for general health without the high sugar content.
90 Value

Omega 3 Platinum

Zahler
4.8
(1395 ratings)
Although more expensive per serving ($0.69), this product delivers a very high dose of quality Kosher TG Fish Oil (3000mg with 1860mg Omega-3s) compared to the unspecified 510mg in SmartyPants gummies. For specific fish oil benefits, this is a far superior value despite the higher initial cost, offering concentrated and bioavailable Omega-3s.
95 Performance

Two-Per-Day Capsules

Life Extension
4.7
(85932 ratings)
This multi offers significantly higher and more bioavailable forms of many vitamins and minerals compared to SmartyPants, including potent doses of B vitamins, Vitamin D3, and a robust antioxidant blend with Lycopene and CoQ10. Its comprehensive formulation and superior ingredient forms make it a much more effective choice for overall health support, though at a higher price.
90 Performance

Men's Once Daily

Garden of Life MyKind Organics
4.8
(2878 ratings)
This organic, whole-food based multivitamin offers a distinct advantage for those preferring natural sources, providing a good profile of essential nutrients, including Lycopene and a solid Vitamin K dose. While its potency isn't always higher than synthetic multis, its whole-food approach and clean label make it a superior choice for specific consumer preferences.
92 Performance

Super Ubiquinol CoQ10 with Enhanced Mitochondrial Support 100 mg

Life Extension
4.7
(8037 ratings)
While a specialized product, it offers a superior and more potent form of CoQ10 (Ubiquinol at 100mg) compared to the Ubiquinone in SmartyPants, along with Shilajit for enhanced mitochondrial support. For individuals specifically targeting heart health and cellular energy, this is a significantly more effective option than the multi-purpose gummy.