Stackexpand_less
Analysisexpand_less
Please sign in to access analysis.
Profileexpand_less
Supplementsexpand_more
Respiratory Support & Defense
Nature's Secret
4.6
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
(727 ratings)
PABA 50 mg
Fenugreek 100 mg
Score 15.0
This product is explicitly designed for respiratory support, containing ingredients like NAC and Mullein. However, it is being analyzed against goals such as muscle gain, testosterone support, and skin health, for which its formulation is largely irrelevant and inadequately dosed. This fundamental misalignment results in a very low efficacy score for the specified objectives.
Quantity: 60 Tablet(s)Servings size: 2 Tablet(s) (30 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Skin Health
Hair Health
Immunity
Detoxification
Brain Health
leaderboard Score 15.0
This product is explicitly designed for respiratory support, containing ingredients like NAC and Mullein. However, it is being analyzed against goals such as muscle gain, testosterone support, and skin health, for which its formulation is largely irrelevant and inadequately dosed. This fundamental misalignment results in a very low efficacy score for the specified objectives.
The Nature's Secret Respiratory Support & Defense product is formulated with a range of herbs and compounds, including N-Acetyl-L-Cysteine (NAC), Mullein, Marshmallow extract, Garlic, and Thyme, which are widely recognized and traditionally used for their benefits in supporting respiratory function and lung health. However, the requested analysis goals for this product are Muscle Gain, Weight Gain, Mood Support, Testosterone Support, Metabolism Boost, Skin Health, and Hair Health. There is a significant and clear disconnect between the product's actual composition and its likely intended use versus the specified goals. While it contains Fenugreek (100mg) and PABA (50mg), the dosages of these ingredients are generally low when compared to what is typically studied or used for their potential effects related to metabolism, testosterone, or hair/skin health. Online reviews and nutritionist perspectives predominantly link these types of ingredients to respiratory wellness, confirming the product's primary focus is not on the listed performance, hormonal, or aesthetic goals.
- The product contains ingredients that are well-regarded for their traditional use in supporting respiratory health, aligning with its actual name and likely intended purpose.
- It offers an affordable price per serving, making it accessible for individuals seeking general wellness or respiratory-focused supplements.
- The inclusion of N-Acetyl-L-Cysteine (NAC) at 300mg provides a recognized ingredient for its antioxidant and mucolytic properties, although not for the specified goals.
- There is a severe mismatch between the product's ingredient profile and the specified analysis goals (Muscle Gain, Weight Gain, Mood Support, Testosterone Support, Metabolism Boost, Skin Health, Hair Health).
- Many ingredients are present in very low dosages, making them unlikely to elicit significant physiological effects related to the specified goals, or even for their traditional respiratory uses.
- The presence of a 'Proprietary Blend' hides the exact quantities of some ingredients within that blend, hindering a full assessment of efficacy.
- Despite containing Fenugreek and PABA, their dosages are too low to be effective for the high-impact goals listed, such as testosterone support or comprehensive skin/hair benefits, especially compared to dedicated supplements.
- This product is not designed or formulated to achieve the specified analysis goals of muscle gain, weight gain, mood support, testosterone support, metabolism boost, skin health, or hair health.
- Consumers seeking specific benefits related to these goals should look for products with ingredients scientifically supported and adequately dosed for those purposes.
- Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any new supplement, particularly if you have underlying health conditions or are taking other medications.
$14.99($0.49 per serving)
 Vitacost | $ 19.99 | |
 Amazon | $ 14.99 | |
 Pure Formulas | $ 14.99 | |
 iHerb | $ 14.99 |
| Ingredient | Amount per serving |
|---|---|
| N-Acetyl-L-Cysteine | 300 mg |
| Fenugreek powder | 100 mg |
| Marshmallow extract | 100 mg |
| Mullein (Verbascum thapsus) powder | 100 mg |
| Skullcap powder | 80 mg |
| PABA | 50 mg |
| Watercress powder | 50 mg |
| Garlic powder | 30 mg |
| Onion powder | 30 mg |
| Pleurisy root powder | 30 mg |
| Turnip powder | 30 mg |
| Thyme powder | 10 mg |
| Proprietary Blend | 102 mg |
Categories
Fenugreek 40.0
The product contains 100mg of Fenugreek powder. While Fenugreek is a versatile herb with potential benefits for digestion, blood sugar, and some male health aspects, the provided dosage is significantly lower than the 500-600mg or more typically used in studies to observe these effects. Therefore, its contribution from this collection is minimal.
PABA 40.0
The product includes 50mg of PABA. PABA is known as part of the B-complex vitamins and has anecdotal associations with hair health and skin. However, this dosage is modest compared to standalone PABA supplements which often offer 500mg to 1000mg per serving, limiting its impact for specific PABA-related benefits.
Goals
Skin Health 15.0
PABA (50mg) is included and has been anecdotally associated with skin health, but strong scientific evidence for general skin improvement or anti-aging effects at this dosage is limited. The product lacks key skin-supporting nutrients like collagen, hyaluronic acid, or specific antioxidants often found in dedicated skin health formulas.
Hair Health 15.0
PABA (50mg) is sometimes included in hair supplements for its supposed role in hair pigment retention, but its efficacy for promoting hair growth or preventing hair loss is not strongly supported by robust clinical data at this dosage. The product does not contain ingredients like biotin, collagen, or silica that are commonly found and better evidenced for hair health.
Mood Support 10.0
While Skullcap is included (80mg) and traditionally associated with calming effects, its dosage is low for significant mood impact, and the overall blend is not specifically designed for comprehensive mood support. Dedicated mood supplements often include adaptogens like Ashwagandha or specific neurotransmitter precursors at higher concentrations.
Recommended Alternatives
90 Value 
Fenugreek 600 mg
Nature's Answer
4.4
★★★★★
(390 ratings)
This alternative offers Fenugreek (600mg), which is six times the amount found in the original product (100mg), at an excellent price per serving. This provides significantly more of a key ingredient for proportionally less cost, offering great value for Fenugreek specific benefits.
88 Value 
B-50
NOW
4.7
★★★★★
(30076 ratings)
This B-complex product includes PABA (25mg) and offers a comprehensive range of B vitamins for general health support. Despite having half the PABA of the original, its extremely low price per serving and broad nutrient profile make it an exceptional value for overall wellness.
85 Value 
B-50 Complex 50 mg
Source Naturals
4.7
★★★★★
(2521 ratings)
This alternative provides a balanced B-complex, including PABA (30mg), at a very economical price per serving. It's a solid option for comprehensive B vitamin support and PABA inclusion, offering good value for general health benefits.
85 Performance 
Fenugreek Extract 500 mg
Swanson
4.7
★★★★★
(278 ratings)
This alternative offers a much higher and standardized dose of Fenugreek (500mg extract vs 100mg powder in original). While not a multi-ingredient blend, it provides a superior and more potent form of one of the original product's key components.
90 Performance 
PABA 1000 mg
Country Life
4.6
★★★★★
(1292 ratings)
This product delivers a significantly higher dosage of PABA (1000mg vs 50mg in original), one of the collection ingredients of the original product. For individuals seeking higher potency PABA, this is a clear improvement.
78 Performance 
Supreme Vital Hair with MSM
LifeTIME
4.5
★★★★★
(455 ratings)
Although positioned for hair/skin, this product contains a higher dose of PABA (200mg) compared to the original, along with other beneficial ingredients like L-Cysteine and MSM known for general health and detoxification support, making it a more potent option for shared or related benefits despite a higher price per serving.
70 Budget 
Fenugreek 610 mg
21st Century
4.6
★★★★★
(993 ratings)
This alternative offers Fenugreek (610mg) at a much higher dose than the original product (100mg Fenugreek powder) for a significantly lower price per serving. While the original product is a blend, this provides a key shared ingredient at a better cost.
75 Budget 
Betaine Hydrochloride 500 mg With Fenugreek
Natural Factors
4.7
★★★★★
(3700 ratings)
This product contains Fenugreek (100mg) at the same dose as the original, along with Betaine HCl, and is substantially cheaper per serving. It offers similar Fenugreek content for a better price point.
80 Budget 
Balance B-50 Complex Comprehensive Formula
Swanson
4.8
★★★★★
(873 ratings)
Providing PABA (50mg), which is a 'collection' ingredient in the original product, along with a comprehensive B-complex, this alternative offers a broader range of general wellness benefits at a significantly lower price per serving.
90 Value
Fenugreek 600 mg
Nature's Answer
4.4
★★★★★
(390 ratings)
This alternative offers Fenugreek (600mg), which is six times the amount found in the original product (100mg), at an excellent price per serving. This provides significantly more of a key ingredient for proportionally less cost, offering great value for Fenugreek specific benefits.
88 Value
B-50
NOW
4.7
★★★★★
(30076 ratings)
This B-complex product includes PABA (25mg) and offers a comprehensive range of B vitamins for general health support. Despite having half the PABA of the original, its extremely low price per serving and broad nutrient profile make it an exceptional value for overall wellness.
85 Value
B-50 Complex 50 mg
Source Naturals
4.7
★★★★★
(2521 ratings)
This alternative provides a balanced B-complex, including PABA (30mg), at a very economical price per serving. It's a solid option for comprehensive B vitamin support and PABA inclusion, offering good value for general health benefits.
85 Performance
Fenugreek Extract 500 mg
Swanson
4.7
★★★★★
(278 ratings)
This alternative offers a much higher and standardized dose of Fenugreek (500mg extract vs 100mg powder in original). While not a multi-ingredient blend, it provides a superior and more potent form of one of the original product's key components.
90 Performance
PABA 1000 mg
Country Life
4.6
★★★★★
(1292 ratings)
This product delivers a significantly higher dosage of PABA (1000mg vs 50mg in original), one of the collection ingredients of the original product. For individuals seeking higher potency PABA, this is a clear improvement.
78 Performance
Supreme Vital Hair with MSM
LifeTIME
4.5
★★★★★
(455 ratings)
Although positioned for hair/skin, this product contains a higher dose of PABA (200mg) compared to the original, along with other beneficial ingredients like L-Cysteine and MSM known for general health and detoxification support, making it a more potent option for shared or related benefits despite a higher price per serving.