Product Image

MaculaPF

Jarrow Formulas
4.6
(2540 ratings)
Astaxanthin 4 mg
Choline 10 mg
Product Image
Score 85.0

MaculaPF is a premium vision support supplement, delivering clinically relevant doses of Lutein, Zeaxanthin, and Astaxanthin for optimal eye health. While comprehensive for ocular needs, its minimal choline content means it isn't effective for broader cognitive or metabolic goals.

Quantity: 30 Softgel(s)Servings size: 1 Softgel(s) (30 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Vision Support
Anti-Aging
Skin Health
Heart Health
Joint Health

Score 85.0

MaculaPF is a premium vision support supplement, delivering clinically relevant doses of Lutein, Zeaxanthin, and Astaxanthin for optimal eye health. While comprehensive for ocular needs, its minimal choline content means it isn't effective for broader cognitive or metabolic goals.

Analysis

MaculaPF is designed with a strong focus on eye health, featuring 20mg Lutein and 13mg Zeaxanthin, dosages consistent with those found effective in studies like AREDS2 for supporting macular health and reducing the risk of age-related macular degeneration. The 4mg of Astaxanthin from Haematococcus pluvialis is a valuable addition, providing potent antioxidant protection for the eyes and contributing to overall cellular health. While the label lists 'Choline' (10mg from sunflower lecithin), this amount is extremely low and is unlikely to provide any significant benefit for cognitive function or other choline-dependent processes, positioning it more as a component of the lecithin carrier rather than an active ingredient for brain support. The product is highly regarded for its specific vision-supporting properties based on ingredient profile and dosages.

Pros
  • Contains optimal, research-backed doses of Lutein (20mg) and Zeaxanthin (13mg) essential for macular health and visual performance.
  • Includes a beneficial dose of Astaxanthin (4mg), a powerful antioxidant, providing enhanced protection against oxidative stress for the eyes and skin.
  • Uses high-quality, bioavailable forms of ingredients like Haematococcus pluvialis for astaxanthin and marigold for lutein/zeaxanthin.
  • Positive online reviews often highlight perceived benefits for eye strain and vision clarity.
Cons
  • The choline content (10mg) is negligible and insufficient to effectively address brain health, cognitive support, or mental focus goals.
  • Claims for broad goals such as 'Metabolism Boost' and 'Productivity Boost' are not strongly supported by the product's specialized ingredient profile.
  • The product is highly specialized for vision, which may not appeal to users looking for a multi-faceted supplement for all listed goals.
Warnings
  • Individuals specifically seeking substantial cognitive benefits or a choline supplement should be aware that the choline dose in this product is too low to be effective.
  • This product is not a substitute for a balanced diet and regular eye examinations.
$17.99($0.59 per serving)
Daily Vita
$ 17.99
Amazon
$ 23.94
Pure Formulas
$ 17.99
iHerb
$ 22.93
Vitacost
$ 17.99
Ingredients
IngredientAmount per serving
Choline (Sunflower Lecithin) 10 mg
Lutein (Marigold) 20 mg
Zeaxanthin (Marigold) 13 mg
Astaxanthin (Haematococcus pluvialis) 4 mg
Adults 18–50
Categories
Astaxanthin 80.0
The product contains 4mg of Astaxanthin from Haematococcus pluvialis, which is a common and effective dose for antioxidant and eye health benefits. This dose is comparable to many standalone astaxanthin supplements and is a strong, valuable component of the formulation within the astaxanthin collection.
Choline 10.0
The choline content is extremely low (10mg) and derived from sunflower lecithin, which typically contains a small percentage of phosphatidylcholine. This amount is far below effective doses for supplementing choline for cognitive or liver health, making its contribution to the choline collection negligible.
Goals
Vision Support 95.0
This product features a potent combination of 20mg Lutein and 13mg Zeaxanthin, precisely the dosages shown in the AREDS2 study to support macular health and visual function. The addition of 4mg Astaxanthin further enhances antioxidant protection for the eyes, making it highly effective for this primary goal.
Anti-Inflammatory Support 70.0
Astaxanthin is a powerful antioxidant and anti-inflammatory compound, and the 4mg dose contributes significantly to reducing oxidative stress and inflammation throughout the body. While not its sole focus, this ingredient provides a notable benefit in this area.
Skin Health 65.0
Astaxanthin is well-regarded for its skin benefits, including protection against UV damage and improving skin elasticity and moisture, due to its strong antioxidant properties. The 4mg dose offers a good contribution towards skin health and appearance.
92 Value

Astaxanthin 12 mg

California Gold Nutrition
4.7
(40091 ratings)
Offers significantly more Astaxanthin per serving at a lower price, making it an excellent value for enhanced antioxidant protection.
90 Value

Extra Strength Astaxanthin 10 mg

NOW
4.7
(8588 ratings)
Delivers a much higher dose of Astaxanthin for a considerably lower price per serving, providing great value for this key ingredient.
88 Value

Astaxanthin with AstaReal 6 mg

Doctor's Best
4.7
(2786 ratings)
Provides a higher dose of Astaxanthin from a reputable source (AstaReal) at a significantly better price per serving.
85 Performance

Antarctic Krill Oil

Dr. Mercola
4.6
(2663 ratings)
Offers broader benefits with a good dose of Antarctic Krill Oil, providing omega-3s, Astaxanthin, and Choline for overall brain, heart, and anti-inflammatory support.
88 Performance

Dynamic Krill Oil

Stonehenge Health
4.3
(211 ratings)
Provides a higher concentration of Krill Oil (1.6g) with Astaxanthin, offering more potent omega-3 and phospholipid benefits.
90 Performance

KrillMD

1MD
4.8
(200 ratings)
Features a high dose of quality Krill Oil (1.6g K-REAL) with specified EPA/DHA and Astaxanthin, providing superior omega-3 and antioxidant benefits.
85 Budget

Astaxanthin 4 mg

NOW
4.7
(4888 ratings)
Provides the same Astaxanthin dose at a significantly lower price per serving, focusing on one of the key antioxidants.
90 Budget

Choline & Inositol

NOW
4.8
(19061 ratings)
Offers a substantial dose of Choline, one of the ingredients in the original, at a much more affordable price per serving.
90 Budget

Astaxanthin 10 mg

Lake Avenue Nutrition
4.7
(5689 ratings)
Delivers a higher dose of Astaxanthin for a considerably lower price per serving, offering excellent antioxidant value.
92 Value

Astaxanthin 12 mg

California Gold Nutrition
4.7
(40091 ratings)
Offers significantly more Astaxanthin per serving at a lower price, making it an excellent value for enhanced antioxidant protection.
90 Value

Extra Strength Astaxanthin 10 mg

NOW
4.7
(8588 ratings)
Delivers a much higher dose of Astaxanthin for a considerably lower price per serving, providing great value for this key ingredient.
88 Value

Astaxanthin with AstaReal 6 mg

Doctor's Best
4.7
(2786 ratings)
Provides a higher dose of Astaxanthin from a reputable source (AstaReal) at a significantly better price per serving.
85 Performance

Antarctic Krill Oil

Dr. Mercola
4.6
(2663 ratings)
Offers broader benefits with a good dose of Antarctic Krill Oil, providing omega-3s, Astaxanthin, and Choline for overall brain, heart, and anti-inflammatory support.
88 Performance

Dynamic Krill Oil

Stonehenge Health
4.3
(211 ratings)
Provides a higher concentration of Krill Oil (1.6g) with Astaxanthin, offering more potent omega-3 and phospholipid benefits.
90 Performance

KrillMD

1MD
4.8
(200 ratings)
Features a high dose of quality Krill Oil (1.6g K-REAL) with specified EPA/DHA and Astaxanthin, providing superior omega-3 and antioxidant benefits.