Product Image

Thyroid Support

Gaia Herbs
4.6
(2249 ratings)
Ashwagandha 80 mg
Iodine 100 mcg
Product Image
Score 65.0

A larger, more cost-effective liquid thyroid support blend with adequate iodine but an underdosed and undisclosed Ashwagandha component, limiting comprehensive efficacy.

Quantity: 120 Liquid(s)Servings size: 2 Capsule(s) (60 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Stress Relief
Energy
Mood Support
Mental Focus
Sleep Support

Score 65.0

A larger, more cost-effective liquid thyroid support blend with adequate iodine but an underdosed and undisclosed Ashwagandha component, limiting comprehensive efficacy.

Quantity: 60
Analysis

This variant of Gaia Herbs Thyroid Support shares the identical ingredient profile and dosage breakdown with the smaller bottle, making the analysis of its potential efficacy largely similar. It effectively delivers 200mcg of iodine, which is critical for healthy thyroid function and subsequent metabolic processes. However, the explicitly listed 80mg of Ashwagandha extract remains a significant limitation, as this amount is considerably less than the evidence-based dosages (typically 300-600mg for standardized extracts) required to achieve meaningful adaptogenic effects on stress, energy, mood, or cognitive function. The continued presence of a 630mg 'Proprietary Extract Blend' without specifying the individual component dosages means consumers cannot fully gauge the product's overall potency for its broad health claims. The primary advantage of this larger size is a more favorable price per serving, offering slightly better value for those committed to the product's formula despite its transparency issues.

Pros
  • Contains a well-dosed amount of Iodine (200mcg) essential for thyroid function.
  • Utilizes natural sources of Iodine (Kelp and Brown Seaweed).
  • Liquid form may appeal to users who prefer not to swallow pills and potentially offers better absorption.
  • Offers a better price per serving ($0.82) compared to the smaller quantity, providing improved value.
  • From a reputable brand, Gaia Herbs, known for quality herbal products.
Cons
  • The explicitly listed Ashwagandha dose of 80mg is very low and likely ineffective for significant adaptogenic benefits.
  • The 'Proprietary Extract Blend' lacks transparency, making it impossible to ascertain the effective dosages of other beneficial ingredients.
Warnings
  • Individuals with pre-existing thyroid conditions (e.g., hyperthyroidism, Hashimoto's thyroiditis) should consult a healthcare professional before taking iodine supplements, as excessive intake can exacerbate certain conditions.
  • Ashwagandha can interact with certain medications, including sedatives, immunosuppressants, and thyroid hormones; medical advice is recommended.
$49.49($0.82 per serving)
Amazon
$ 49.49
Pure Formulas
$ 49.49
iHerb
$ 49.49
Ingredients
IngredientAmount per serving
Calories 5 Calorie(s)
Total Carbohydrates 2 Gram(s)
Iodine (Kelp, Brown Seaweed) 100 mcg
Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera) root extract 80 mg
Proprietary Extract Blend 630 mg
Adults 18–50 Women
Categories
Iodine 80.0
The product provides 200mcg of Iodine, which is a sufficient and safe daily dose to support thyroid hormone production and general iodine requirements.
Ashwagandha 30.0
With only 80mg of Ashwagandha extract explicitly listed, this dosage is considerably lower than what is typically recommended and clinically effective for most of Ashwagandha's known benefits.
Goals
Metabolism Boost 75.0
The 200mcg of Iodine is directly supportive of thyroid hormone production, which is a primary regulator of metabolism in the body.
General Health 60.0
Iodine is vital for general health, particularly thyroid function. However, the low Ashwagandha dose and proprietary blend limit its holistic contribution to broad general health benefits.
Energy 50.0
Adequate iodine supports thyroid function which impacts energy levels. However, the adaptogenic Ashwagandha component is unlikely to provide a strong energy boost at this minimal dose.
90 Value

Kelp 325 mcg

Nutricost
4.9
(204 ratings)
An extremely cost-effective option for iodine supplementation, providing a significant 325mcg dose from kelp at a very low price per serving, offering excellent value for basic thyroid mineral needs.
88 Value

Ashwagandha Root Extract 450 mg

California Gold Nutrition
4.7
(5501 ratings)
Provides a solid 450mg dose of Ashwagandha root extract at an attractive price per serving, representing good value for those seeking effective adaptogenic support without premium pricing.
85 Value

M.V. Teen

Futurebiotics
4.8
(22224 ratings)
This multivitamin includes a foundational dose of iodine (150mcg) alongside a wide array of vitamins and minerals, offering broad nutritional support and exceptional value for comprehensive daily supplementation.
93 Performance

Ultimate Ashwagandha 250 mg KSM-66

Swanson
4.7
(2147 ratings)
Features KSM-66, a highly researched and potent form of Ashwagandha, providing superior efficacy for stress reduction and adaptogenic benefits compared to the generic extract in the original product.
91 Performance

Ferodrox

Kaged Muscle
4.3
(576 ratings)
While a multi-ingredient product, it includes a high dose of KSM-66 Ashwagandha (600mg), making it a superior choice for effective adaptogenic and stress-relief benefits due to the quality of the extract.
89 Performance

Kelp Whole Thallus 600 mg

Nature's Way
4.7
(11483 ratings)
Offers a slightly higher dose of iodine (270mcg) derived from whole thallus kelp, a natural and comprehensive source, supporting robust thyroid function more effectively.
86 Budget

Arctic-Kelp 225 mcg

Country Life
4.9
(7981 ratings)
Provides a targeted iodine supplement from natural Arctic Kelp at a minimal cost per serving, making it a highly economical choice for basic thyroid iodine support.
89 Budget

Ashwagandha 450 mg

Swanson
4.7
(22387 ratings)
Delivers a substantial 450mg dose of Ashwagandha per serving at a very low price, offering a much more potent and cost-effective option for adaptogenic and stress-relief support.
87 Budget

Daily Vits

NOW
4.7
(9895 ratings)
A comprehensive multivitamin offering a full spectrum of essential nutrients, including iodine, at a significantly lower price point, serving as a more complete nutritional foundation.
90 Value

Kelp 325 mcg

Nutricost
4.9
(204 ratings)
An extremely cost-effective option for iodine supplementation, providing a significant 325mcg dose from kelp at a very low price per serving, offering excellent value for basic thyroid mineral needs.
88 Value

Ashwagandha Root Extract 450 mg

California Gold Nutrition
4.7
(5501 ratings)
Provides a solid 450mg dose of Ashwagandha root extract at an attractive price per serving, representing good value for those seeking effective adaptogenic support without premium pricing.
85 Value

M.V. Teen

Futurebiotics
4.8
(22224 ratings)
This multivitamin includes a foundational dose of iodine (150mcg) alongside a wide array of vitamins and minerals, offering broad nutritional support and exceptional value for comprehensive daily supplementation.
93 Performance

Ultimate Ashwagandha 250 mg KSM-66

Swanson
4.7
(2147 ratings)
Features KSM-66, a highly researched and potent form of Ashwagandha, providing superior efficacy for stress reduction and adaptogenic benefits compared to the generic extract in the original product.
91 Performance

Ferodrox

Kaged Muscle
4.3
(576 ratings)
While a multi-ingredient product, it includes a high dose of KSM-66 Ashwagandha (600mg), making it a superior choice for effective adaptogenic and stress-relief benefits due to the quality of the extract.
89 Performance

Kelp Whole Thallus 600 mg

Nature's Way
4.7
(11483 ratings)
Offers a slightly higher dose of iodine (270mcg) derived from whole thallus kelp, a natural and comprehensive source, supporting robust thyroid function more effectively.