Product Image

Prenatal Formula

SmartyPants
4.5
(22181 ratings)
Iodine 290 mcg
Fish Oil 455 mg
Choline 55 mg
Vitamin K 24 mcg
Product Image
Score 60.0

SmartyPants Prenatal Formula is a popular gummy prenatal, appreciated for its taste and convenience, and contains beneficial active forms of folate and B12, along with a good dose of iodine. However, it is significantly underdosed in several key prenatal nutrients, most notably choline, and lacks crucial minerals like calcium and iron, making it an incomplete prenatal option and necessitating additional supplementation. The high sugar content inherent to gummies is also a notable drawback.

Quantity: 120 Gummy(ies)Servings size: 4 Gummy(ies) (30 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
General Health
Brain Health
Productivity Boost
Metabolism Boost
Energy

Score 60.0

SmartyPants Prenatal Formula is a popular gummy prenatal, appreciated for its taste and convenience, and contains beneficial active forms of folate and B12, along with a good dose of iodine. However, it is significantly underdosed in several key prenatal nutrients, most notably choline, and lacks crucial minerals like calcium and iron, making it an incomplete prenatal option and necessitating additional supplementation. The high sugar content inherent to gummies is also a notable drawback.

Analysis

The SmartyPants Prenatal Formula offers a gummy format, which is often favored for ease of consumption, especially for individuals experiencing nausea during pregnancy. It notably includes active forms of Folate (L-Methylfolate) and Vitamin B12 (Methylcobalamin), which are superior for absorption and beneficial for those with MTHFR gene variations. The Iodine content is also robust, meeting and exceeding recommended daily allowances for pregnant women, which is crucial for fetal brain development. However, a significant drawback is the underdosing of several other critical nutrients, such as Thiamine, Riboflavin, Biotin, Zinc, Selenium, and especially Choline, with only 55mg compared to the recommended 450mg and often higher optimal intakes. The "Fish Oil" amount is also generic, without specified EPA/DHA, making it difficult to assess if it meets the critical 200-300mg DHA recommendation for fetal neurodevelopment. Furthermore, the absence of calcium and iron, two fundamental minerals in prenatal nutrition, is a major omission, requiring separate supplementation. The gummy form also comes with a notable 9 grams of sugar per serving, which contributes to calorie intake without significant nutritional benefit.

Pros
  • Convenient and easy-to-take gummy form, appealing to those with pill aversion or morning sickness.
  • Includes active and bioavailable forms of Folate (L-Methylfolate) and Vitamin B12 (Methylcobalamin).
  • Contains a sufficient and beneficial amount of Iodine for thyroid function and fetal brain development.
  • Fish Oil is included, contributing to omega-3 intake (though DHA content is unspecified).
Cons
  • Critically lacks Iron and Calcium, two essential minerals for pregnant women, necessitating separate supplementation.
  • Severely underdosed in Choline (55mg vs. 450mg AI), a vital nutrient for fetal brain development.
  • Many B vitamins (Thiamine, Riboflavin, Biotin, Zinc, Selenium) are significantly underdosed compared to prenatal recommendations.
  • Gummy form results in high sugar content (9g carbohydrates per serving), adding unnecessary calories.
  • Fish oil quantity (455mg) is generic and likely provides insufficient DHA compared to recommended prenatal levels (200-300mg DHA).
Warnings
  • This product does not contain Iron or Calcium, which are critical for preventing anemia and supporting bone health during pregnancy; additional supplementation for these minerals will be necessary.
  • The low dose of Choline may not provide optimal support for fetal brain development, as recommended intake is significantly higher.
  • Individuals should be mindful of the high sugar content, which may not be ideal for daily consumption, especially for those managing blood sugar levels.
$27.95($0.93 per serving)
Amazon
$ 34.99
Walmart
$ 36.99
Pure Formulas
$ 27.95
iHerb
$ 29.71
Vitacost
$ 31.39
Ingredients
IngredientAmount per serving
Calories 40 Calorie(s)
Cholesterol 5 mg
Total Carbohydrates 9 Gram(s)
Vitamin A (Retinyl Palmitate, Beta-Carotene) 520 mcg
Vitamin C (Ascorbic Acid) 48 mg
Vitamin D (Vitamin D3, Cholecalciferol) 30 mcg
Vitamin E (D-Alpha-Tocopherol) 14.3 mg
Vitamin K (Vitamin K1) 24 mcg
Thiamine (Vitamin B1, Thiamine Mononitrate) 0.14 mg
Riboflavin (Vitamin B2) 0.16 mg
Niacin (Vitamin B3, Inositol Niacinate) 18 mg
Vitamin B-6 (Pyridoxal 5-Phosphate) 2 mg
Folate (L-Methylfolate, Calcium Salt) 600 mcg DFE
Vitamin B12 (Methylcobalamin) 4.7 mcg
Biotin 17.5 mcg
Choline (Choline Bitartrate) 55 mg
Iodine (Potassium Iodide) 290 mcg
Zinc (Zinc Citrate) 3.9 mg
Selenium (Sodium Selenite) 14 mcg
Sodium 25 mg
Fish Oil 455 mg
Inositol (Inositol Niacinate) 5 mg
Vitamin K-2 (Menaquinone-7) 16 mcg
Gluten Free Dairy Free Pregnant
Categories
Iodine 90.0
At 290mcg (from Potassium Iodide), the Iodine dosage is excellent and well above the recommended daily intake of 220mcg for pregnant women, providing robust support for thyroid function and fetal neurodevelopment.
Vitamin K 65.0
The product includes both Vitamin K1 (24mcg) and K2 (16mcg), which is a good combination. While the total of 40mcg is not exceptionally high, it meets the general daily requirements and offers the benefits of two forms.
Fish Oil 50.0
While Fish Oil (455mg) is present, the specific amounts of crucial DHA and EPA are not listed. Given the total, it is highly probable that the DHA content falls short of the recommended 200-300mg per day for optimal fetal brain and eye development, making its overall contribution to omega-3 needs limited.
Goals
General Health 60.0
As a prenatal, it covers some essential vitamins like Folate, B12, and Iodine adequately. However, the numerous underdosed ingredients and complete absence of others (Iron, Calcium) mean it provides only partial support for overall general health during pregnancy.
Brain Health 55.0
While it includes Folate and Vitamin B12 in good, active forms, and fish oil, the extremely low dosage of choline (55mg vs. 450mg AI) and unspecified DHA content severely limit its efficacy for comprehensive brain health and neurodevelopment.
Heart Health 55.0
The inclusion of Fish Oil offers some support for heart health, but the unspecified and likely low DHA/EPA content, along with general nutrient deficiencies, means it provides only a minimal contribution to cardiovascular well-being.
80 Value

Prenatal Blend

Super Nutrition
4.5
(1930 ratings)
This prenatal blend delivers a more comprehensive nutrient profile, including a superior form and higher dose of Vitamin K2 (85mcg) and adequate iodine, for a significantly lower price per serving ($0.36 vs $0.92). This offers excellent overall value for a prenatal supplement.
85 Value

Choline & Inositol

NOW
4.8
(19061 ratings)
This product provides 250mg of Choline Bitartrate per serving, which is more than four times the amount found in SmartyPants, at a remarkably low price of $0.08 per serving. This represents exceptional value for boosting choline intake, a crucial nutrient during pregnancy.
88 Value

Kelp Whole Thallus 600 mg

Nature's Way
4.7
(11483 ratings)
Offering 270mcg of Iodine per serving at just $0.07, this alternative provides a highly comparable and effective dose of iodine to the SmartyPants product, but at a vastly more affordable price per serving, delivering superior value for this essential mineral.
90 Performance

Choline & Inositol

Nature's Way
4.8
(3224 ratings)
This alternative provides a robust 500mg of Choline Bitartrate per serving, significantly more than the SmartyPants' 55mg, directly addressing a major deficiency for prenatal brain development. Its comprehensive choline content makes it a superior choice for this vital nutrient.
80 Performance

Prenatal Blend

Super Nutrition
4.5
(1930 ratings)
As another prenatal blend, this product offers a better form of Vitamin K (K2 at 85mcg) which is superior for bone and cardiovascular health compared to the low dose of K1 in SmartyPants. It provides a more comprehensive and balanced prenatal profile, even at a lower price per serving.
90 Performance

Vitamins D and K with Sea-lodine

Life Extension
4.8
(20811 ratings)
While not a full prenatal, this supplement offers exceptionally high doses of Vitamin K (2100mcg) and Iodine (1000mcg), significantly surpassing the SmartyPants product in these critical areas. This makes it a highly effective targeted supplement for addressing deficiencies in these specific nutrients.
95 Budget

Choline Bitartrate 650 mg

Nutricost
4.8
(381 ratings)
This alternative offers an excellent 650mg of Choline per serving, far surpassing the 55mg in the SmartyPants product, and does so at a significantly lower price per serving ($0.07 vs $0.92), making it a much more cost-effective source of this vital prenatal nutrient.
90 Budget

Kelp

Swanson
4.7
(2247 ratings)
Providing 225mcg of Iodine from Kelp at just $0.02 per serving, this product offers a highly affordable way to obtain an adequate and comparable dose of Iodine to the SmartyPants prenatal, making it an excellent budget-friendly choice for this specific nutrient.
75 Budget

Omega-3 Fish Oil 1000 mg Lemon

Natrol
4.8
(13312 ratings)
At $0.07 per serving, this fish oil product offers a very affordable source of Omega-3s, which are notably lacking in specified quantity in the SmartyPants Prenatal. It directly addresses a critical component of prenatal health at a fraction of the cost.
80 Value

Prenatal Blend

Super Nutrition
4.5
(1930 ratings)
This prenatal blend delivers a more comprehensive nutrient profile, including a superior form and higher dose of Vitamin K2 (85mcg) and adequate iodine, for a significantly lower price per serving ($0.36 vs $0.92). This offers excellent overall value for a prenatal supplement.
85 Value

Choline & Inositol

NOW
4.8
(19061 ratings)
This product provides 250mg of Choline Bitartrate per serving, which is more than four times the amount found in SmartyPants, at a remarkably low price of $0.08 per serving. This represents exceptional value for boosting choline intake, a crucial nutrient during pregnancy.
88 Value

Kelp Whole Thallus 600 mg

Nature's Way
4.7
(11483 ratings)
Offering 270mcg of Iodine per serving at just $0.07, this alternative provides a highly comparable and effective dose of iodine to the SmartyPants product, but at a vastly more affordable price per serving, delivering superior value for this essential mineral.
90 Performance

Choline & Inositol

Nature's Way
4.8
(3224 ratings)
This alternative provides a robust 500mg of Choline Bitartrate per serving, significantly more than the SmartyPants' 55mg, directly addressing a major deficiency for prenatal brain development. Its comprehensive choline content makes it a superior choice for this vital nutrient.
80 Performance

Prenatal Blend

Super Nutrition
4.5
(1930 ratings)
As another prenatal blend, this product offers a better form of Vitamin K (K2 at 85mcg) which is superior for bone and cardiovascular health compared to the low dose of K1 in SmartyPants. It provides a more comprehensive and balanced prenatal profile, even at a lower price per serving.
90 Performance

Vitamins D and K with Sea-lodine

Life Extension
4.8
(20811 ratings)
While not a full prenatal, this supplement offers exceptionally high doses of Vitamin K (2100mcg) and Iodine (1000mcg), significantly surpassing the SmartyPants product in these critical areas. This makes it a highly effective targeted supplement for addressing deficiencies in these specific nutrients.