Product Image

Eye Remedy Tangerine Smoothie

Barlean's

4.7
(20 ratings)
Astaxanthin 2 mg
Product Image
Score 78.0

A liquid eye health smoothie with Lutein, Zeaxanthin, Astaxanthin, and Omega-3s, highly palatable and bioavailable, but very expensive per serving.

Quantity: 16 Ounce(s)Servings size: 16 Gram(s) (28 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Skin Health
Vision Support
Heart Health
Joint Health
Anti-Inflammatory Support

Score 78.0

A liquid eye health smoothie with Lutein, Zeaxanthin, Astaxanthin, and Omega-3s, highly palatable and bioavailable, but very expensive per serving.

Analysis

Barlean's Eye Remedy Tangerine Smoothie is an innovative approach to eye health supplements, delivered as a pleasant-tasting liquid smoothie. It contains a good dose of 12mg Lutein, 2mg Zeaxanthin, and 2mg Astaxanthin, synergistically combined with 1250mg Omega-3 Polyunsaturated Fats, Grape Seed Extract, and Blueberry Extract. The smoothie format can be highly bioavailable and easier for some to consume than pills. However, with only 1 serving (16 oz total) at a price of $29.20, its price per serving is exceptionally high ($29.20), making it impractical for consistent daily use and significantly reducing its value proposition despite its quality ingredients.

Pros
  • Unique liquid smoothie form enhances palatability and potentially bioavailability.
  • Combines key eye nutrients (Lutein, Zeaxanthin, Astaxanthin) with beneficial Omega-3s and fruit extracts.
  • Natural tangerine flavor makes it enjoyable to consume.
Cons
  • Extremely high price per serving, making it cost-prohibitive for long-term daily use.
  • Low astaxanthin dose (2mg) for the premium price.
  • Only 1 serving per container, which is unusual for a supplement intended for daily intake.
Warnings
  • Refrigeration required after opening, which may be inconvenient for some users.
  • Serving size discrepancy (16 oz as 1 serving, likely meant to be multiple servings of smaller volume).
Report analysis
$29.20($1.04 per serving)
iHerb
$ 29.20
Report prices

Effectiveness for goals

Dosage, timing & forms

Safety & interactions

Ingredients

IngredientAmount per serving
Calories
60 Calorie(s)
Total Fat
4 Gram(s)
Cholesterol
25 mg
Total Carbohydrates
6 Gram(s)
Omega-3 Polyunsaturated Fat
1250 mg
Lutein
12 mg
Zeaxanthin Isomers
2.5 mg
Astaxanthin, Natural
2 mg
Blueberry Extract
75 mg
Grape Seed Extract
25 mg
Gluten Free Adults 18–50 Dairy Free Sugar Free
Report overview

Categories

Within the Astaxanthin category, its 2mg astaxanthin dose is quite low for the extremely high price per serving, positioning it as a specialized eye health blend rather than a competitive astaxanthin supplement.

Goals

This product offers strong vision support through its blend of Lutein, Zeaxanthin, Astaxanthin, and Omega-3s, which are all crucial for eye health. The liquid delivery may also enhance absorption, making it very effective for targeted eye benefits.
The inclusion of 1250mg of Omega-3s, combined with the antioxidant properties of astaxanthin and fruit extracts, provides some benefits for cardiovascular health, supporting healthy lipid profiles and reducing oxidative stress.
The combination of astaxanthin and Omega-3s provides good anti-inflammatory and antioxidant support. However, for high-level anti-inflammatory benefits, higher doses of these ingredients are often preferred, especially considering the product's cost.
85 Value

Ultimate Ocular Antioxidant

Swanson
4.7
(136 ratings)
This Swanson product offers a powerful blend of 20mg Lutein, 4mg Zeaxanthin, and 4mg Astaxanthin at a dramatically lower price per serving (59 cents vs. $29.20), providing outstanding value for comprehensive eye support.
90 Value

MacuGuard Ocular Support with Saffron & Astaxanthin

Life Extension
4.6
(5474 ratings)
Life Extension's MacuGuard provides a sophisticated blend with 6mg astaxanthin, lutein, and saffron for 53 cents per serving, offering exceptional value for a premium, multi-ingredient eye formula compared to the Barlean's smoothie.
75 Value

Omega Pals Hooty Fuity Tangerine Flavor

Barlean's Seriously Delicious
4.5
(3564 ratings)
This alternative offers a similar liquid, flavored approach from the same brand, including Omega-3s, Lutein, Zeaxanthin, and some astaxanthin, at a significantly more reasonable overall product price, making it a better value for a liquid eye support product.
95 Performance

MacuGuard Ocular Support with Saffron & Astaxanthin

Life Extension
4.6
(5474 ratings)
This Life Extension product is better due to its higher astaxanthin dose (6mg vs 2mg), and the inclusion of saffron, a premium ingredient for visual acuity, alongside a balanced complex of other ocular nutrients in a more cost-effective capsule form.
90 Performance

Ultimate Ocular Antioxidant

Swanson
4.7
(136 ratings)
This Swanson product is better due to its significantly higher doses of Lutein (20mg vs 12mg) and Astaxanthin (4mg vs 2mg), offering a more potent and effective combination of key eye carotenoids at a much more reasonable price point.
90 Performance

Eye Support

Dr. Mercola
4.6
(697 ratings)
Dr. Mercola's Eye Support offers a strong, organic blend of 10mg Lutein, 2mg Zeaxanthin, 2mg Astaxanthin, and 50mg Anthocyanins, providing a very well-rounded and high-quality alternative for comprehensive eye care in a more conventional and cost-effective capsule form.
85 Budget

Ultimate Ocular Antioxidant

Swanson
4.7
(136 ratings)
This Swanson product offers 20mg Lutein, 4mg Zeaxanthin, and 4mg Astaxanthin at a significantly lower price per serving (59 cents vs. $29.20), providing a comprehensive eye blend at a fraction of the cost.
90 Budget

MacuGuard Ocular Support with Saffron & Astaxanthin

Life Extension
4.6
(5474 ratings)
Life Extension's MacuGuard offers 6mg astaxanthin, lutein, zeaxanthin, and saffron for 53 cents per serving, providing a potent and much more affordable alternative for combined eye nutrients.
75 Budget

Omega Pals Hooty Fuity Tangerine Flavor

Barlean's Seriously Delicious
4.5
(3564 ratings)
From the same brand, this Omega-3 blend offers Lutein, Zeaxanthin, and 1mg Astaxanthin at a much lower price ($20.69 for a larger quantity), making it a more economical liquid alternative for eye health with Omega-3s.
85 Value

Ultimate Ocular Antioxidant

Swanson
4.7
(136 ratings)
This Swanson product offers a powerful blend of 20mg Lutein, 4mg Zeaxanthin, and 4mg Astaxanthin at a dramatically lower price per serving (59 cents vs. $29.20), providing outstanding value for comprehensive eye support.
90 Value

MacuGuard Ocular Support with Saffron & Astaxanthin

Life Extension
4.6
(5474 ratings)
Life Extension's MacuGuard provides a sophisticated blend with 6mg astaxanthin, lutein, and saffron for 53 cents per serving, offering exceptional value for a premium, multi-ingredient eye formula compared to the Barlean's smoothie.
75 Value

Omega Pals Hooty Fuity Tangerine Flavor

Barlean's Seriously Delicious
4.5
(3564 ratings)
This alternative offers a similar liquid, flavored approach from the same brand, including Omega-3s, Lutein, Zeaxanthin, and some astaxanthin, at a significantly more reasonable overall product price, making it a better value for a liquid eye support product.
95 Performance

MacuGuard Ocular Support with Saffron & Astaxanthin

Life Extension
4.6
(5474 ratings)
This Life Extension product is better due to its higher astaxanthin dose (6mg vs 2mg), and the inclusion of saffron, a premium ingredient for visual acuity, alongside a balanced complex of other ocular nutrients in a more cost-effective capsule form.
90 Performance

Ultimate Ocular Antioxidant

Swanson
4.7
(136 ratings)
This Swanson product is better due to its significantly higher doses of Lutein (20mg vs 12mg) and Astaxanthin (4mg vs 2mg), offering a more potent and effective combination of key eye carotenoids at a much more reasonable price point.
90 Performance

Eye Support

Dr. Mercola
4.6
(697 ratings)
Dr. Mercola's Eye Support offers a strong, organic blend of 10mg Lutein, 2mg Zeaxanthin, 2mg Astaxanthin, and 50mg Anthocyanins, providing a very well-rounded and high-quality alternative for comprehensive eye care in a more conventional and cost-effective capsule form.
Report alternatives