Product Image

Black Elderberry Syrup

Gaia Herbs

4.8
(4614 ratings)
European Elder 476 mg
Acerola 37 mg
Product Image
Score 55.0

A low-calorie elderberry syrup with notably lower active ingredient concentrations than other options, leading to diminished effectiveness for its price.

Quantity: 3 Fluid Ounce(s)Servings size: 1 mL (71 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Immunity
General Health
Cardiovascular Support
Anti-Inflammatory Support
Skin Health

Score 55.0

A low-calorie elderberry syrup with notably lower active ingredient concentrations than other options, leading to diminished effectiveness for its price.

Analysis

This standard Black Elderberry Syrup from Gaia Herbs provides 476mg of Black Elderberry and 37mg of Acerola extract per serving. While elderberry is well-regarded for immune support, this dosage is considerably lower than what's found in the 'NightTime' versions from the same brand or many comparable alternatives, which often offer 500mg-1000mg+ of elderberry extract per serving. Although it boasts 0 calories and 1g of carbohydrates, its higher price per serving for a reduced concentration of active compounds makes it a less efficient choice for those seeking potent immune support.

Pros
  • Contains 0 calories and only 1g of carbohydrates per serving, suitable for those monitoring sugar intake.
  • Utilizes Black Elderberry and Acerola, known for their immune-supporting and antioxidant properties.
Cons
  • The dosage of Black Elderberry (476mg) and Acerola (37mg) is considerably lower than many alternative products and even other Gaia Herbs elderberry syrups.
  • The price per serving ($0.32) is higher than the 'NightTime' versions from the same brand, despite offering a lower concentration of key active ingredients.
  • May not provide sufficient potency for those seeking robust immune support during acute illness.
Warnings
  • Consumers should be aware of the lower active ingredient concentration when comparing effectiveness and value.
Report analysis
$22.94($0.32 per serving)
Amazon
$ 22.94
iHerb
$ 22.94
Report prices

Effectiveness for goals

Dosage, timing & forms

Safety & interactions

Ingredients

IngredientAmount per serving
Calories
0 Calorie(s)
Total Carbohydrates
1 Gram(s)
Black Elderberry (Sambucus nigra) fruit juice concentrate
476 mg
Acerola fruit extract
37 mg
Gluten Free Adults 18–50 Vegan Women Organic Children 4+ Children 1–4 Vegetarian
Report overview

Categories

Provides European Elder, but the concentration (476mg) is comparatively low for a dedicated elderberry product when stronger options are available.
The Acerola content (37mg) is quite low, offering minimal contribution as a significant source of Vitamin C.

Goals

While containing elderberry, the 476mg dosage is on the lower side for significant immune support, especially compared to higher-potency alternatives.
The modest amounts of elderberry and acerola offer some general antioxidant benefits, but its contribution to overall health is limited due to the lower concentration.
The antioxidant and anti-inflammatory compounds are present, but at a lower concentration, their impact on reducing inflammation is less pronounced.
85 Value

Sambucus Black Elderberry 1000 mg

Nature's Truth
4.7
(32174 ratings)
Delivers a much higher elderberry concentration (1000mg) at a fraction of the price per serving, making it a significantly better value for high-dose elderberry.
82 Value

Black Elderberry

Nature's Way
4.7
(18890 ratings)
Offers a substantial 920mg of European Elder per serving at a very reasonable price, providing significantly more active ingredient per dollar than the analyzed syrup.
80 Value

Sambucus Zinc-C

NOW
4.9
(18081 ratings)
Combines a respectable 150mg elderberry concentrate with Vitamin C and Zinc at a very low price per serving, offering synergistic immune benefits at an excellent value.
88 Performance

Elderberry Complex

SR Sports Research
4.7
(2681 ratings)
Features a higher potency ElderCraft® extract alongside beneficial additions like Vitamin C, D3, Zinc, and Ginger, offering a more comprehensive and potent immune formula than a basic elderberry syrup.
85 Performance

ImmunAbreve

Advanced Nutrition by Zahler
4.7
(99 ratings)
This alternative provides a broader immune-supportive complex with a higher elderberry dose and synergistic ingredients like Vitamin C, Echinacea, Garlic, and Astragalus for enhanced effectiveness.
78 Performance

Sambucus Hot Drink Mix Honey Lemon-Berry Flavored

Nature's Way
4.7
(863 ratings)
Offers a higher dose of elderberry combined with Vitamin C and Echinacea in a comforting hot drink format, providing more active ingredients than the analyzed syrup for immune support.
75 Budget

Elderberry 450 mg

Solaray
4.8
(721 ratings)
This capsule alternative offers a comparable elderberry dose (450mg vs 476mg) at a significantly lower price per serving, providing similar benefits much more economically.
65 Budget

Sambucus Vitamin C Lozenges Wild Cherry Flavored

Nature's Way
4.7
(837 ratings)
While a lozenge, it provides elderberry and Vitamin C at a much lower price per serving, offering a convenient and cheaper way to get immune support on the go.
80 Budget

Elderberry 575 mg

Nutricost
4.7
(1407 ratings)
This alternative provides a higher elderberry dose per serving in capsule form at an extremely low price, representing a much more cost-efficient option for daily elderberry supplementation.
85 Value

Sambucus Black Elderberry 1000 mg

Nature's Truth
4.7
(32174 ratings)
Delivers a much higher elderberry concentration (1000mg) at a fraction of the price per serving, making it a significantly better value for high-dose elderberry.
82 Value

Black Elderberry

Nature's Way
4.7
(18890 ratings)
Offers a substantial 920mg of European Elder per serving at a very reasonable price, providing significantly more active ingredient per dollar than the analyzed syrup.
80 Value

Sambucus Zinc-C

NOW
4.9
(18081 ratings)
Combines a respectable 150mg elderberry concentrate with Vitamin C and Zinc at a very low price per serving, offering synergistic immune benefits at an excellent value.
88 Performance

Elderberry Complex

SR Sports Research
4.7
(2681 ratings)
Features a higher potency ElderCraft® extract alongside beneficial additions like Vitamin C, D3, Zinc, and Ginger, offering a more comprehensive and potent immune formula than a basic elderberry syrup.
85 Performance

ImmunAbreve

Advanced Nutrition by Zahler
4.7
(99 ratings)
This alternative provides a broader immune-supportive complex with a higher elderberry dose and synergistic ingredients like Vitamin C, Echinacea, Garlic, and Astragalus for enhanced effectiveness.
78 Performance

Sambucus Hot Drink Mix Honey Lemon-Berry Flavored

Nature's Way
4.7
(863 ratings)
Offers a higher dose of elderberry combined with Vitamin C and Echinacea in a comforting hot drink format, providing more active ingredients than the analyzed syrup for immune support.
Report alternatives