Product Image

Melatonin 5 mg

Natrol

4.6
(8048 ratings)
Melatonin 5 mg
Vitamin B6 10 mg
Product Image
Score 80.0

A higher-dose 5mg melatonin supplement from Natrol with Vitamin B6, effective for stronger sleep support but less cost-efficient than bulk options.

Quantity: 60 Tablet(s)Servings size: 1 Tablet(s) (60 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Stress Relief
Anti-Aging
Sleep Support
Energy
Brain Health

Score 80.0

A higher-dose 5mg melatonin supplement from Natrol with Vitamin B6, effective for stronger sleep support but less cost-efficient than bulk options.

Analysis

This Natrol Melatonin 5 mg supplement is designed for individuals seeking a more potent dose of melatonin to aid with sleep. The 5mg dosage is often chosen when 3mg proves insufficient, providing a stronger signal to the body for sleep induction. Like other Natrol melatonin products, it includes 10mg of Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxine Hydrochloride) to support the body's natural sleep-regulating neurotransmitters. While highly reviewed for effectiveness, its smaller serving size (60 counts) results in a higher price per serving compared to bulk options, which is a consideration for long-term users.

Pros
  • Higher 5mg melatonin dose is effective for individuals needing stronger sleep support.
  • Includes Vitamin B6, which contributes to neurotransmitter synthesis and overall nervous system health.
  • Supported by a very high number of positive customer reviews, indicating strong efficacy for many users.
  • From Natrol, a well-established and trusted brand in the supplement industry.
Cons
  • The price per serving ($0.14) is relatively high compared to other melatonin products, including Natrol's own larger count options.
  • The Vitamin B6 is in the pyridoxine hydrochloride form, which some users find less bioavailable than P-5-P.
  • The 5mg dose might be excessive for some users, potentially leading to unwanted grogginess or dependence.
Report analysis
$8.27($0.13 per serving)
Amazon
$ 8.27
Vitacost
$ 9.79
iHerb
$ 10.39
Walmart
$ 14.74
Report prices

Effectiveness for goals

Dosage, timing & forms

Safety & interactions

Ingredients

IngredientAmount per serving
Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxine Hydrochloride) 10 mg
Calcium (Calcium Carbonate) 63 mg
Melatonin 5 mg
Adults 18–50 Dairy Free Children 4+ Vegetarian
Report overview

Categories

The 5mg dosage is a common and effective strength for many individuals, particularly those needing more significant sleep aid. Natrol is a reputable brand for melatonin, ensuring product reliability and purity.
The 10mg dose of Vitamin B6 is sufficient for its supportive role in neurotransmitter synthesis, which complements melatonin's effects on sleep and mood. However, the use of pyridoxine hydrochloride rather than the more bioavailable P-5-P form means it may not be optimally absorbed by all users.

Goals

With a potent 5mg dose of melatonin, this product is highly effective for regulating sleep cycles and promoting faster sleep onset, especially for those who find lower doses insufficient. The synergistic B6 further aids in the body's natural sleep processes.
Improved, restful sleep directly reduces stress and enhances the body's coping mechanisms, making this product valuable for stress relief. The inclusion of Vitamin B6 further supports the nervous system and neurotransmitter balance, which are crucial for managing stress.
Adequate sleep is a cornerstone of stable mood, reducing irritability and enhancing emotional resilience. Vitamin B6 further contributes by aiding in the synthesis of critical mood-regulating neurotransmitters like serotonin and dopamine.
89 Value

Melatonin 3 mg

NOW
4.8
(4544 ratings)
While a 3mg melatonin dose, it includes 3mg of B6 and offers a significantly lower price per serving ($0.03 vs $0.14), making it a much better value for a similar melatonin-B6 combination from a reputable brand.
85 Value

Melatonin 3 mg

Natrol
4.6
(6922 ratings)
This is another Natrol product, offering 3mg melatonin and 10mg B6, but at a much lower price per serving ($0.07 vs $0.14) due to its larger serving count, providing a more economical Natrol option.
92 Value

Advanced Sleep Melatonin 10 mg Time Release

Natrol
4.5
(62726 ratings)
Despite a slightly lower price per serving ($0.11 vs $0.14), this Natrol product offers a higher 10mg melatonin dose with time-release technology, potentially providing more sustained sleep benefits and better overall value for advanced sleep needs.
92 Performance

Melatonin 5.0 mg Orange Flavor

Source Naturals Sleep Science
4.5
(62 ratings)
Offers the same 5mg melatonin dose but includes the more bioavailable Coenzymated Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxal 5-Phosphate), which may offer better B6 absorption and synergistic effects for sleep and mood.
90 Performance

Insomnitol

Designs for Health
4.6
(32 ratings)
This product is a comprehensive sleep-aid blend that contains 10mg of the superior P-5-P form of Vitamin B6, indicating a more advanced and multi-faceted approach to addressing sleep issues beyond just melatonin.
89 Performance

Power to Sleep PM

Irwin Naturals
4.3
(2630 ratings)
As a multi-ingredient sleep formula, this alternative provides a broader range of herbal and nutrient support for relaxation and sleep, potentially offering more comprehensive benefits for individuals struggling with various aspects of sleep disturbance.
90 Budget

Melatonin 5 mg

NOW
4.7
(11948 ratings)
Offers the same 5mg melatonin dose at half the price per serving ($0.07 vs $0.14), providing a significantly more economical option for equivalent melatonin strength without added B6.
88 Budget

Melatonin 5 mg

Spring Valley
4.6
(3117 ratings)
Provides a 5mg melatonin dosage at a substantially lower price per serving ($0.04 vs $0.14), making it a highly cost-effective choice for basic 5mg melatonin supplementation.
85 Budget

Melatonin 1 mg

Spring Valley
4.5
(278 ratings)
While a lower dose at 1mg, its price per serving ($0.04 vs $0.14) is significantly cheaper, offering an extremely budget-friendly option for those who only need minimal melatonin support.
89 Value

Melatonin 3 mg

NOW
4.8
(4544 ratings)
While a 3mg melatonin dose, it includes 3mg of B6 and offers a significantly lower price per serving ($0.03 vs $0.14), making it a much better value for a similar melatonin-B6 combination from a reputable brand.
85 Value

Melatonin 3 mg

Natrol
4.6
(6922 ratings)
This is another Natrol product, offering 3mg melatonin and 10mg B6, but at a much lower price per serving ($0.07 vs $0.14) due to its larger serving count, providing a more economical Natrol option.
92 Value

Advanced Sleep Melatonin 10 mg Time Release

Natrol
4.5
(62726 ratings)
Despite a slightly lower price per serving ($0.11 vs $0.14), this Natrol product offers a higher 10mg melatonin dose with time-release technology, potentially providing more sustained sleep benefits and better overall value for advanced sleep needs.
92 Performance

Melatonin 5.0 mg Orange Flavor

Source Naturals Sleep Science
4.5
(62 ratings)
Offers the same 5mg melatonin dose but includes the more bioavailable Coenzymated Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxal 5-Phosphate), which may offer better B6 absorption and synergistic effects for sleep and mood.
90 Performance

Insomnitol

Designs for Health
4.6
(32 ratings)
This product is a comprehensive sleep-aid blend that contains 10mg of the superior P-5-P form of Vitamin B6, indicating a more advanced and multi-faceted approach to addressing sleep issues beyond just melatonin.
89 Performance

Power to Sleep PM

Irwin Naturals
4.3
(2630 ratings)
As a multi-ingredient sleep formula, this alternative provides a broader range of herbal and nutrient support for relaxation and sleep, potentially offering more comprehensive benefits for individuals struggling with various aspects of sleep disturbance.
Report alternatives