Select Protein Amazing Cake Pop

Select Protein Amazing Cake Pop

PEScience4.4 (3,380 ratings)
Format:Powder Quantity: 30 Ounce(s) · 27 servings
$49.99 $1.85 per serving
AmazonLowest$49.99iHerb$54.99

Product analysis

42 out of 100

Select Protein Amazing Cake Pop offers a flavored source of protein, but its unspecified protein source makes the ingredient quality harder to compare with alternatives.

AI assessment of the formula, label and price. How scoring works

Nutrient Quality20

The protein and other ingredient preparations are unspecified, limiting reliable quality comparisons. An unspecified calcium source also leaves its form quality unclear.

Ingredient Transparency56

Most nutrient amounts are stated, but the vitamin D amount is undisclosed. Ingredient sources and preparations are unspecified, making the protein and mineral forms harder to compare.

Value For Money39

The calcium-related serving comparison is relatively expensive, while the sodium-related comparison is moderate. The protein content cannot be judged reliably for value, leaving the main buying comparison unresolved.

Customer Satisfaction81

A large number of customers give generally positive feedback. Those opinions do not establish nutritional effectiveness or suitability.

Product Focus36

Protein is the clearest focus of the formula. A specific performance benefit cannot be assessed confidently from the nutrient list alone.

Format
Powder
Container
30 Ounce(s)
Per serving
$1.85
Customer rating
4.4 · 3,380 ratings
Report analysis

Ingredients

IngredientAmount per servingScore
Calories
120 Calorie(s)
Total Fat
1 Gram(s)
Cholesterol
45 mg
Sodium
250 mg 60
Total Carbohydrates
2 Gram(s)
Protein
24 Gram(s)
Vitamin D
0 mcg
Calcium
280 mg 33
Potassium
10 mg
Iron
0.2 mg
Gluten Free Adults 18–50
Report overview
Sodium · 250 mg OverallScore60
D Active Ingredient Quality & BioavailabilityB Dose, Safety & Label TransparencyD+ Value
The serving supplies 250 mg sodium at a high whole-product cost per serving. The sodium source is unspecified. It also lists 10 mg potassium.
How this ingredient is rated

Active Ingredient Quality & Bioavailability48

The sodium source is unspecified. The serving also lists 10 mg potassium; their forms are not fully specified in the available information.
Sodium Source Purity & Quality
The sodium source is unspecified.
Bioavailability of Supporting Electrolytes
The serving also lists 10 mg potassium; their forms are not fully specified in the available information.
Trace Mineral Complex & Buffering Forms
No additional trace mineral or buffering component is established.

Dose, Safety & Label Transparency77

The serving provides 250 mg sodium. The available information indicates an artificial sweetener.
Sodium Dosage for Athletic Replenishment
The serving provides 250 mg sodium.
Ingredient Label Transparency
The sodium amount is stated, as are the listed amounts of 10 mg potassium.
Artificial Color and Sweetener Disclosure
The available information indicates an artificial sweetener.

Value50

The whole-product cost per serving is high.
Price Per Serving vs. Collection Median
The whole-product cost per serving is high.
View ingredientView products
Calcium · 280 mg OverallScore33
F Active Ingredient Quality & BioavailabilityD- Dose, Safety & Label TransparencyF Value
It offers a 280 mg serving at a high cost per serving. The calcium source is unknown. An artificial additive is listed.
How this ingredient is rated

Active Ingredient Quality & Bioavailability30

The label states the calcium amount. The calcium source is unknown.
Calcium Form & Absorption Potential
The calcium source is unknown.
Elemental Calcium Transparency
The label states 280 mg of calcium per serving.

Dose, Safety & Label Transparency42

Each serving provides 280 mg of calcium. An artificial additive is listed, and the serving contains 1 g of sugar.
Absorption-Optimized Serving Dose
Each serving provides 280 mg of calcium.
Formulation Purity & Additives
An artificial additive is listed, and the serving contains 1 g of sugar.

Value20

The cost per serving is high.
Price Per Serving Efficiency
The cost per serving is high.
View ingredientView products
75 Performance

Micellar Casein Unflavored

California Gold Nutrition SPORT

A more useful protein-and-mineral profile provides 25 g of protein, 650 mg of calcium, and only 35 mg of sodium in 110 calories. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it improves both calcium coverage and sodium control while preserving a full protein serving.

79 Performance

Paleo Thin Egg White Protein 24 g Unflavored

Julian Bakery

A more useful protein-and-mineral profile provides 24 g of protein with no fat or cholesterol and only 1 g of carbohydrate. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it keeps protein comparable while removing the fat and cholesterol listed in the originals, although sodium is higher.

72 Performance

Classic ALLWHEY Cookies & Cream

ALLMAX

A more useful protein-and-mineral profile provides 30 g of protein, 180 mg of calcium, and 230 mg of sodium. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it raises protein meaningfully, with a trade-off of more calories and carbohydrate than most targets.

79 Budget

Casein Protein Elite Series Triple Chocolate

Six Star Pro Nutrition

A lower serving cost still provides 24 g of protein, 580 mg of calcium, and 180 mg of sodium. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it keeps protein close to the original while supplying more calcium than every target in this group.

75 Budget

Organic Protein French Vanilla

Purely Inspired

A lower serving cost still provides 22 g of protein, 150 mg of calcium, and 290 mg of sodium. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it offers a plant-based protein option, though its sodium is higher and its protein is slightly lower than the originals.

81 Budget

Whey Protein Isolate Vanilla

Kaged

A lower serving cost still provides 25 g of protein, 124 mg of calcium, and 160 mg of sodium in 110 calories. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it matches or exceeds the targets’ protein with a leaner calorie profile and moderate sodium.

74 Value

HEXAPRO Chocolate

ALLMAX

A practical value balance combines 25 g of protein, 245 mg of calcium, and 210 mg of sodium with a lower serving cost. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it maintains the same protein level as the HEXAPRO targets and stays close to the PEScience products on calcium.

65 Value

Complete Protein Creamy Vanilla Bean

PlantFusion

A practical value balance combines 21 g of protein, an amino-acid blend, and an enzyme blend with a lower serving cost. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it provides a plant-based formula with added amino acids, but has less protein and considerably more sodium than the originals.

64 Value

Nitro-Tech Milk Chocolate

MuscleTech

A practical value balance combines 30 g of protein, 140 mg of calcium, and 270 mg of sodium with a lower serving cost. Compared with the original’s 24 g protein, 280 mg calcium, and 250 mg sodium, it delivers more protein for a competitive serving cost, though calcium is lower and sodium is not especially restrained.

Report alternatives