Product Image

First Defense

ChildLife Essentials

4.8
(5244 ratings)
St. John's Wort 20 mg
Product Image
Score 15.0

First Defense is poorly aligned with its stated goals of mood, stress, and sleep support due to an extremely low dosage of St. John's Wort (40mg) and the inclusion of predominantly immune-focused ingredients. Its effectiveness for the stated goals is questionable.

Quantity: 4 Fluid Ounce(s)Servings size: 3 mL (24 servings)
Selected goals:
Other goals:
Mood Support
Stress Relief
Sleep Support

Score 15.0

First Defense is poorly aligned with its stated goals of mood, stress, and sleep support due to an extremely low dosage of St. John's Wort (40mg) and the inclusion of predominantly immune-focused ingredients. Its effectiveness for the stated goals is questionable.

Analysis

The product "First Defense" by ChildLife Essentials, despite its name suggesting immune support, is specified to target Mood Support, Stress Relief, and Sleep Support. Its formulation, however, primarily includes ingredients recognized for immune function, such as Larch Arabinogalactan, Elderberry, and Zinc. The sole ingredient relevant to the stated goals, St. John's Wort, is present in a significantly low dosage of 40mg per serving. This is far below the generally accepted therapeutic doses (typically 300mg three times daily or higher) for adults, and even for children, it's unlikely to provide a noticeable effect for mood, stress, or sleep, making it largely ineffective for its purported goals when compared to specialized alternatives.

Pros
  • Contains ingredients known for general immune support (Larch Arabinogalactan, Elderberry, Zinc), which could be beneficial for overall well-being in children if that were the explicit goal.
  • Liquid form, which is often preferred for children.
Cons
  • Severely underdosed St. John's Wort: The 40mg dosage is vastly insufficient for therapeutic effects on mood, stress, or sleep, especially when compared to alternative products.
  • Mismatch with stated goals: The majority of ingredients (Larch Arabinogalactan, Grindelia robusta, Elderberry, Olive, Zinc) are primarily associated with immune or respiratory support, not mood, stress, or sleep.
  • Potential for consumer confusion: The product name and ingredient profile suggest immune support, while the stated goals are for mood/stress/sleep, leading to misalignment of expectations.
Warnings
  • Consumers seeking effective mood, stress, or sleep support, especially through St. John's Wort, will likely find this product ineffective due to its low dosage.
  • St. John's Wort can interact with numerous medications, although the extremely low dose in this product makes significant interactions less likely, it's still a general caution for the ingredient.
  • The product is from a children's brand; while St. John's Wort can be used in children under medical supervision, this specific formulation and dosage are unlikely to provide meaningful benefits for the stated goals.
Report analysis
$17.56($0.73 per serving)
Pure Formulas
$ 17.56
Vitacost
$ 17.96
Amazon
$ 17.96
iHerb
$ 17.96
Report prices

Effectiveness for goals

Dosage, timing & forms

Safety & interactions

Ingredients

IngredientAmount per serving
Calories
5 Calorie(s)
Total Carbohydrates
1 Gram(s)
Zinc
3 mg
Olive
80 mg
Elderberry
80 mg
Grindelia robusta
80 mg
St. John's Wort
20 mg
Larch Arabinogalactan
15 mg
Gluten Free Dairy Free All Children Infants 0–1
Report overview

Categories

While St. John's Wort is present, its dosage of 40mg is negligible when compared to other St. John's Wort products on the market, which typically offer 300mg to 900mg per serving. This product does not provide a therapeutically relevant amount of the herb for its traditional uses.

Goals

The product's effectiveness for mood, stress, and sleep support is severely hampered by the extremely low concentration of St. John's Wort (40mg). Scientific evidence supports St. John's Wort for these purposes at much higher dosages (e.g., 300mg 3x daily), making this formulation largely ineffective for its stated goals in comparison to more potent alternatives available.
Report alternatives